3D Systems Q3 Revenue Down 2% to $31.5M, Net Loss of $11.3M
VALENCIA,
California, February 5, 2007 - 3D Systems Corporation (NASDAQ: TDSC), a
leading provider of Rapid 3-D Printing, Prototyping and Manufacturing
solutions, released its restated financial statements for the first and
second quarters of 2006 and prior periods today. Separately, the company
also reported its operating results for the third quarter and first nine
months of 2006. The company also filed its Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for
the quarter ended September 30, 2006 with the SEC today.
Restatement
As the company announced on December 14, 2006, it has restated its annual
financial statements for its 2004 and 2005 calendar years. The effect of
these restatements was to increase net income available to common
stockholders in 2004 by $0.5 million, or $0.04 per share on a fully diluted
basis, and to decrease net income available to common stockholders in 2005
by $0.7 million, or $0.05 per share on a fully diluted basis. These amounts
are consistent with the expectations that the company announced last month.
Each quarterly period in 2005 was also restated, and the effect of those
restatements has been included in the 2005 operating results discussed
below.
The company has also restated its financial statements for the first two
quarters of 2006. The effect of these restatements was to increase net loss
available to common stockholders in the first quarter of 2006 by $0.7
million, or $0.05 per share, and to increase net loss available to common
stockholders in the second quarter of 2006 by $2.6 million, or $0.16 per
share. These amounts are also consistent with the expectations that the
company announced last month.
As the company previously disclosed, it identified the errors that led to
these restatements in the third quarter of 2006. These errors primarily
include errors in recording customer credits and deposits and to a lesser
extent (i) errors identified in reconciling fixed asset and
construction-in-progress accounts and related depreciation and (ii) errors
identified during the reconciliation of a number of income and expense
accounts and accrued liabilities. As noted above, in the restatements, these
errors primarily impacted the first and second quarters of 2006. Certain of
the errors identified with respect to the 2004 and 2005 financial statements
reflected the effect on those years of the 2006 errors that the company
identified and the remainder of them primarily included unrelated previously
unadjusted audit differences with respect to 2004 and 2005 that were
evaluated when they were identified in prior periods and determined not to
be material to the financial statements at that time. The company recorded
these unadjusted differences in the restatement of the 2004 and 2005
financial statements.
The company identified the errors in the 2006 financial statements
primarily as a result of its efforts to remediate the material weaknesses
that it previously identified and disclosed with respect to its second
quarter 2006 financial statements as well as through its ongoing efforts (a)
to implement its new ERP system, (b) to reconcile the records in its new ERP
system and those in its legacy systems, and (c) to test its internal
controls in the context of the new ERP system environment. In connection
with restating its financial statements, the company identified additional
material weaknesses that it is working to remediate. These material
weaknesses, and the actions the company is taking diligently to remediate
them, are discussed in greater detail in the Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q
that the company filed with the SEC today.
The company encourages anyone who is interested in a detailed analysis of
the restatement to read the company’s Form 10-Q for the quarter ended
September 30, 2006.
Operating Results
In line with its December 14, 2006 announcement, the company reported
revenue for the third quarter of 2006 of $31.5 million, a 2.2% decrease from
restated revenue reported for the third quarter of 2005. Revenue for the
first nine months of 2006 was $92.2 million, a 2.9% decrease from restated
revenue reported for the first nine months of 2005. On a sequential-quarter
basis, revenue increased by 16.0% over the company’s second-quarter 2006
revenue, reflecting the early impact of the corrective action plan that the
company began to implement in July 2006.
Gross profit for the third quarter of 2006 declined to $10.7 million from
$14.7 million in the third quarter of 2005 as restated and declined to $30.2
million from $41.7 million in the first nine months of 2005 as restated.
Net loss available to common stockholders for the third quarter of 2006
was $11.3 million, or $0.61 per fully diluted share, compared to $0.5
million of net income available to common stockholders, or $0.03 per fully
diluted share, in the 2005 quarter as restated. Net loss available to common
stockholders for the first nine months of 2006 was $24.7 million, or $1.48
per fully diluted share, compared to $1.8 million of net income available to
common stockholders, or $0.11 per fully diluted share, in the first nine
months of 2005 as restated. These net losses in the 2006 periods included
$2.5 million of non-cash income tax expense arising out of the recording of
a valuation allowance at September 30, 2006 against the net deferred tax
asset that the company recorded at December 31, 2005 as a result of the
company’s changed outlook.
Consistent with its December 14, 2006 announcement, the company’s
operating performance in the third quarter and first nine months of 2006 was
largely a reflection of the disruptions that it encountered when it started
up its new enterprise resource planning (“ERP”) system in the U.S. and in
most of Europe during the second quarter of 2006, many of which continued to
have an adverse effect on its operations in the third quarter of 2006 with
lessening impact as the third quarter ended. These disruptions, as well as
other interruptions in its supply chain activities arising primarily from
the outsourcing of logistics and warehousing of spare parts to a third-party
logistics provider, more than offset the company’s stronger performance in
the first quarter of 2006. These disruptions made it difficult for the
company to enter and process customer orders, procure and manage inventory,
schedule orders for production and shipping and invoice finished products to
customers during the second quarter and, to a lesser extent, during the
third quarter. The effect of these factors eased toward the end of the third
quarter of 2006 as the company made progress in its remediation efforts and
corrective action plan.
|
Operating Highlights
Third Quarter and First Nine Months
of 2006
($ in millions except for per share
amounts) |
|
Operating Highlights |
Third Quarter |
First Nine Months |
|
2006 |
2005
Restated |
%
Change |
2006 |
2005
Restated |
% Change |
| Revenue |
$31.5 |
$32.2 |
(2%) |
$92.2 |
$95.0 |
(3%) |
Gross profit
% of Revenue |
$10.7
34% |
$14.7
46% |
(27%) |
$30.2
33% |
$41.7
44% |
(28%) |
Operating
expenses
% of Revenue |
$19.4
62% |
$13.4
42% |
45% |
$50.5
55% |
$37.5
39% |
35% |
Operating
income (loss)
% of Revenue |
$(8.7)
NM |
$1.2
4% |
NM |
$(20.4)
NM |
$4.2
4% |
NM |
Net income
(loss) available to common stockholders
% of Revenue |
$(11.3)
NM |
$0.5
2% |
NM |
$(24.7)
NM |
$1.8
2% |
NM |
| Diluted
income (loss) per share available to common
stockholders |
$(0.61) |
$0.03 |
NM |
$(1.48) |
$0.11 |
NM |
| Unrestricted
cash |
$5.3 |
$26.2 |
(80%) |
$5.3 |
$26.2 |
(80%) |
Depreciation
and amortization
% of Revenue |
$1.3
4% |
$1.6
5% |
(6%) |
$4.4
5% |
$4.8
5% |
(8%) |
|
|
|
NM= Not Meaningful
The company ended the third quarter with an approximately $13 million
order backlog, primarily for systems and materials, a majority of which it
expected to ship during the remainder of 2006.
Revenue By Class of Product and Service
($ in millions) |
|
Product or Service |
Third Quarter |
First Nine Months |
|
2006 |
2005
Restated |
% Change |
2006 |
2005
Restated |
% Change |
| Systems and other products |
$9.3 |
$12.0 |
(22)% |
$29.2 |
$33.6 |
(13)% |
| Materials |
$13.4 |
$10.9 |
23% |
$36.8 |
$31.9 |
15% |
| Services |
$8.7 |
$9.3 |
(6)% |
$26.3 |
$29.6 |
(11)% |
| Total |
$31.5 |
$32.2 |
(2)% |
$92.2 |
$95.0 |
(3)% |
*Columns may not add due to rounding.
The residual business disruptions that the company continued to
experience during the third quarter adversely impacted revenue from systems
and services, with significant reductions in unit sales volume in each of
those product and service classes. The company experienced continued revenue
growth from its engineered materials and composites, which were less
susceptible to the ERP and supply chain disruptions, reflecting the relative
simplicity of the sourcing and logistics for these products and the positive
traction that the company is already getting from its implementation of
integrated materials’ packaging and delivery systems into its new class of
systems. The company also reported that, on a geographic basis, the revenue
decline for the first nine months of 2006 was due to a decline in European
revenue, with revenue from the U.S. and Asia-Pacific areas being essentially
even with 2005 revenue as restated.
The decline in gross profit for the third quarter and first nine months
of 2006 was due primarily to the combined effects of lower revenue and ERP
system, supply chain and logistics disruptions that the company encountered.
During the third quarter of 2006, the company continued to extend special
accommodations to certain customers whose orders for products, services or
repairs to systems were delayed by the disruptions that the company
encountered with its ERP system and logistics activities or who encountered
stability issues with their equipment installations that the company was not
able to quickly address as a result of resource and training constraints on
its service organization. These accommodations adversely affected gross
profit during the quarter. The impact of equipment stability and related
resource training constraints eased toward the end of the third quarter of
2006, as the company made significant progress in its training and quality
remediation efforts and corrective action plan. The company believes that
its progress in remediating its new systems’ teething problems and training
gaps resulted in greater market acceptance of its new systems as reflected
in its backlog at the end of the third quarter.
|
Gross Profit Margins
($ in millions) |
| |
Third Quarter |
First Nine Months |
|
2006 |
2005
Restated |
% Change |
2006 |
2005
Restated |
% Change |
Products
% Revenue |
$9.4
41% |
$11.9
52% |
(21%) |
$25.1
38% |
$32.0
49% |
(22%) |
Services
% Revenue |
$1.4
16% |
$2.7
29% |
(50%) |
$5.1
19% |
$9.7
33% |
(47%) |
Total
% Revenue
|
$10.7
34% |
$14.7
46% |
(27%) |
$30.2
33% |
$41.7
44% |
(28%) |
*Columns may not add due to rounding. Gross profit margin on products
decreased to 41% in the third quarter of 2006 from 52% for the third quarter
of 2005 as restated. Gross profit margin for products sold in the first nine
months of 2006 decreased to 38% from 49% for the first nine months of 2005
as restated. The decrease in margins primarily reflects $1.4 million of
inventory write-offs or adjustments resulting from various inventory
reconciliation procedures as well as higher warranty expense as a result of
items previously discussed, special customer accommodations and higher
freight costs.
Gross profit margin on services decreased to 16% of consolidated service
revenue for the third quarter of 2006 from 29% of consolidated service
revenue for the third quarter of 2005 as restated. Gross profit margin on
services decreased to 19% of consolidated service revenue for the first nine
months of 2006 from 33% of consolidated service revenue for the first nine
months of 2005 as restated. During the third quarter, service margins
continued to be impacted by spare parts’ shortages as a result of the ERP
and supply-chain interruptions as well as the strains on resources related
to installation, service and training mentioned above that resulted in
foregone service income from time and materials service activities. Service
margins were also impacted by the absence of legacy system upgrade sales,
which the company has previously announced that it would no longer support.
|
Operating Expenses
($ in millions) |
| |
Third Quarter |
First Nine Months |
|
2006 |
2005
Restated |
% Change |
2006 |
2005
Restated |
% Change |
| SG&A |
$13.8 |
$10.0 |
39% |
$34.8 |
$28.6 |
22% |
| R&D |
$3.9 |
$3.4 |
12% |
$10.1 |
$8.8 |
15% |
| Severance and restructuring |
$1.7 |
NM |
NM |
$5.7 |
NM |
NM |
| Total |
$19.4 |
$13.4 |
45% |
$50.5 |
$37.5 |
35% |
*Columns may not add due to rounding.
NM= Not Meaningful
Total operating expenses increased by $6.0 million to $19.4 million in
the third quarter of 2006 compared to $13.4 million in the third quarter of
2005 as restated and by $13.1 million to $50.5 million in the first nine
months of 2006 compared to $37.5 million in the first nine months of 2005 as
restated.
The increase in operating expenses for the third quarter was due
primarily to $3.9 million of higher selling, general and administrative
expenses, $1.7 million of severance and restructuring costs related to the
relocation of the company’s headquarters to Rock Hill, South Carolina, which
were generally in line with the company’s previously announced expectations,
and $0.4 million of higher research and development expenses.
The increase in operating expenses in the first nine months of 2006 was
due to $6.2 million of higher selling, general and administrative expenses,
$5.7 million of severance and restructuring costs related to the Rock Hill
relocation, and $1.3 million of higher research and development expenses.
As the company previously disclosed, the higher research and development
expenses in each period related to the company’s continuing high level of
new product development work, primarily related to its accelerated work on
the development of additional desktop 3-D Printers, including the recently
announced V-Flash™ desktop modeler, and other Rapid Manufacturing solutions.
The higher selling, general and administrative expenses in each period
resulted mostly from higher consulting expenses primarily related to the
company’s ERP and relocation projects, higher bad debt expense, and non-cash
equity compensation expense related to unvested options.
At the end of the third quarter of 2006, the company had over $5 million
of unrestricted cash recorded on its consolidated balance sheet.
Unrestricted cash increased to approximately $14 million at December 31,
2006. This includes approximately $8 million that the company had drawn at
December 31, 2006 under its $15 million revolving credit line with Silicon
Valley Bank, which as reported in a Form 8-K filing on January 25, 2007 has
been amended on a basis that the company believes to be beneficial. We
believe that both our cash management and our working capital management
improved during the fourth quarter of 2006.
“We are very pleased today to be able to bring our third-quarter filing
to current status and share with you in detail the scope and magnitude of
our restatements and the results of the third quarter,” said Abe Reichental,
3D Systems’ president and chief executive officer.
“As we have already mentioned in our previous, frequent communications,
during the third quarter, we continued to experience a number of challenges
relating to our ERP implementation, the start-up of our recently outsourced
logistics and warehousing activities, and the relocation of our operations,
including the need to hire and train new employees who are not yet fully
experienced with our new ERP system and financial accounting practices or
fully familiar with our business. As you may recall, we started up our new
ERP system in the U.S. on May 1, 2006 and in most of Europe in mid-June
2006. Following the start up of the system, we encountered disruptions in
processing transactions in the system that affected our ability to enter and
process customer orders, procure and manage inventory, schedule orders for
production and shipping and invoice finished products to customers,”
continued Reichental. “As I shared with you earlier in January, we believe
that we have made significant progress in remediating the root causes of
these disruptions and fully expect the ERP system to ultimately improve our
business processes, efficiency and control environment.
“As we have told you over the past several months, we also experienced
significant disruptions in our supply chain activities that led to shortages
of parts and materials, resulting in loss of parts and materials’ revenue, a
consequent loss of service revenue, higher service and expediting costs and
the need to compensate customers who were adversely affected by these
shortages,” continued Reichental. “These shortages also delayed shipments of
finished products.
“Also, as we entered the third quarter, our new, sophisticated, advanced
manufacturing-capable Sinterstation Pro and Viper Pro systems, with their
broader range of capabilities, continued to require extensive commissioning
and training to achieve operating stability and operating potential for some
customers. As a result of the high volume of sales of these systems that we
have enjoyed in recent quarters, and the continued need for additional
commissioning and training time, we have also experienced field service
resource constraints and equipment stability issues that delayed the
start‑up of some systems and impacted our effectiveness in servicing our
higher volume 3-D Printing segment,” continued Reichental. “During the third
quarter, we continued to address all of these issues, and made meaningful
progress by working closely with our customers to resolve system stability
issues in a mutually beneficial manner. We also intensified our own internal
training and provided more extensive customer training, support and
installation activities than the services we traditionally provide with our
legacy systems. While we encountered higher warranty and related costs that
adversely affected our gross profit in the third quarter and first nine
months of 2006, we believe that the remediation efforts we have undertaken
throughout the third quarter and subsequently resulted in improved systems
and organizational performance since the end of the third quarter.
Consequently, we expect to be able to return to normalized operating
conditions as we complete the implementation of our corrective action plan,”
said Reichental.
“Notwithstanding all of these challenges, we are heartened by the fact
that we ended the quarter with a significantly larger backlog of new orders
compared to our historical experience, which we believe suggests that our
lower-than-anticipated results in the third quarter were symptoms of the
disruptions we experienced rather than a fundamental problem with our
business,” continued Reichental.
“We are pleased that, since the beginning of July, the focused execution
against the corrective action plan that we have implemented enabled us to
process and ship the majority of the new order backlog we had at the end of
the third quarter. We believe that the significant backlog and our progress
in shipping it suggests, first, that the demand for our products and
services remains strong and, but for the temporary problems we experienced
in fulfilling orders, would have contributed to a significantly better third
quarter than we experienced and, second, that we are making real progress in
correcting all of these disruptions. While we are not in a position today to
comment in any detail on our performance in subsequent periods, we believe
that our fourth-quarter 2006 revenue will reflect the continuation of the
improving trend with which we exited the third quarter.
“Despite the disappointments that we encountered in the second and third
quarters of 2006, we firmly believe that we have made significant progress
in many areas as we continued to invest in infrastructure, products, people
and capabilities to achieve our strategic objectives.
Specifically, since the beginning of 2006:
- “We completed the consolidation of our corporate headquarters’ and
R&D activities in a new state-of-the-art facility in Rock Hill, South
Carolina;
- “We announced an exclusive agreement with Symyx Technologies to
discover and commercialize advanced materials for use in our Rapid
Prototyping and Rapid Manufacturing solutions;
- “We entered into an agreement to sell our Grand Junction facility
for a $7.0 million cash purchase price, subject to the satisfaction of
certain customary conditions. We expect that transaction to be completed
by the end of the first quarter of 2007;
- “All outstanding shares of our Series B Convertible Preferred Stock
were converted into 3D Systems’ common stock in June, simplifying our
capital structure and reducing our dividend expense for the future;
- “We reported that we have entered into an amendment to the Silicon
Valley Bank credit facility;
- “We are continuing our work to arrange financing for the purchase of
our Rock Hill headquarters;
- “We continued in partnership with York Technical College to develop
a world-class training center adjacent to our new headquarters;
- “We continued to expand our product portfolio consistent with our
key initiatives to grow our Rapid Manufacturing and 3-D Printing base;
and
- “We announced our plans to introduce a new fast, simple and
economical 3-D Printer, the V-Flash™ desktop modeler, capable of
creating stereolithography-like parts in the office, home or school
setting.
"Since the end of the third quarter of 2006, we continued to work to
remedy as promptly as we could all the material weaknesses that we have
identified. Also since the end of the third quarter, we continued to work to
correct all of the remaining ERP, supply-chain, relocation and systems'
stabilization-related issues. We believe that, as of today, the majority of
our operational issues have been resolved successfully, and we expect to
resolve any remaining operational and control issues as promptly as we can
although we currently expect to report that the material weaknesses that we
have identified and disclosed continued at year end. We remain confident in
our overall direction and expect that the key initiatives and investments
that we undertook throughout 2006 will provide us with the right platform to
achieve our long-term objectives," concluded Reichental.
Conference Call and Audio Webcast Details
3D Systems will hold a conference call and audio Webcast to discuss its
third quarter and first nine months’ 2006 financial results this morning at
11:30 a.m. Eastern Time.
To access the Conference Call, dial 1-888-336-3485 (or 706-634-0653 from
outside the United States). A recording will be available two hours after
completion of the call for seven days. To access the recording, dial
1-800-642-1687 (or 706-645-9291 from outside the United States) and enter
8245255, the conference call ID number.
To access the audio Webcast, log onto 3D Systems’ website at
www.3dsystems.com. The link to the
Webcast is provided on the homepage of the website. To ensure timely
participation and technical capability, we recommend logging on a few
minutes prior to the conference call to activate your participation. The
Webcast will be available for replay beginning approximately 48 hours after
completion of the call at:
www.3dsystems.com under the Investor Relations’ section.
About 3D Systems Corporation
3D Systems is a leading provider of Rapid 3-D Printing, Prototyping and
Manufacturing solutions. Its systems and materials reduce the time and cost
of designing products and facilitate direct and indirect manufacturing by
creating actual parts directly from digital input. These solutions are used
for design communication and prototyping as well as for production of
functional end-use parts: Transform your products.
--------
If news like this is important to you, sign up for our
TenLinks Daily at
www.tenlinks.com/NEWS/sub_unsub.htm.
Related News
Apr 22 - 3D Systems Delivers Accura Materials in Japan Apr 9 - Japan's Nihon Weed Buys 3D Systems Sinterstation Pro SLS Apr 9 - Japan's Nihon Weed Buys 3D Systems Sinterstation Pro SLS Apr 2 - 3D Systems Ships V-Flash Desktop Modeler Mar 18 - 3D Systems Q4 Revenue Up 6% to $45M with $1.4M Profit Mar 4 - 3D Systems to Collaborate with TRIAL for Laser Sintering Feb 29 - Sirona Selects 3D Systems InVision DP 3D Modeler Feb 11 - APP Selects 3D Systems Accura Feb 4 - 3D Systems Launches Direct Metal Laser Sintering Systems Jan 22 - 3D Systems to Launch ProJet DP 3000 3D Printer Jan 8 - 3D Systems to Launch ProJet HD3000 3D Printer Jan 8 - APP Buys 3D Systems Viper Pro SLA Dec 17 - 3D Systems to Present at Needham Conference Dec 6 - 3D Systems Announces Nanocomposite for SLA Oct 23 - 3D Systems' Q3 FY 2007 Conference Call on Nov 2, 9AM ET Oct 16 - FineLine Becomes 3D Systems 'Preferred Service Provider' Oct 10 - 400 Attend 3D Systems World Conference Oct 10 - Acu-Cast Buys 3D Systems Viper Pro SLA System Oct 9 - Reebok Adopts 3D Systems DuraForm Flex Plastic Sep 27 - 3D Systems Releases LS 3.44, OptiScan for SLS Systems Sep 27 - 3D systems Launches DuraForm HST Plastic for SLS Systems Sep 27 - 3D Systems Offers Accura 48HTR Rapid Prototype Plastic Sep 27 - 3D Systems to Offer Self-Maintenance Courses Sep 26 - 3D Systems Delivers Software for Viper Pro SLA Sep 25 - 3D Systems Claims Viper Pro SLA Installed in 13 Countries Sep 25 - 3D Systems Launches V-Flash Desktop Modeler Sep 25 - 3D Systems Introduces DuraForm EX Black Plastic Sep 18 - 3D Systems CEO Named Ambassador for Economic... Aug 7 - 3D Systems Q2 Revenue Up 34% to $36M But Loses $5.3M Jul 30 - 3D Systems University Offers InVision 3-D Modeling Course Jul 24 - 3D Systems Announces Accura Xtreme Plastic Jul 24 - 3D Systems Converts 6% Debentures into Common Stock Jul 3 - 3D Systems Launches Accura 55 Plastic Jul 3 - 3D Systems Extends Loan Agreement with Silicon Valley Bank Jun 22 - 3D Systems Calls for Redemption of Convertible Debentures Jun 21 - 3D Systems Announces Private Placement of Common Stock Jun 06 - 3D Systems Selects Canon to Manufacture V-Flash Desktop... Jun 5 - 3D Systems Fixes NASDAQ Deficiency May 31 - National RP 3D Systems Service Provider May 31 - 3D Systems Q1 Revenue Up 9.8% to $37M but Loses $3M May 22 - 3D Systems Receives NASDAQ Delisting Notice May 14 - 3D Systems Delays Filing, Q1 Loss May Exceed $2M May 7 - 3D Systems Cures NASDAQ Deficiency May 2 - 3D Systems FY06 Revenue Down to $134.8M, Q4 Down to... May 1 - 3D Systems Launches InVision XT 3-D Modeler at RAPID Apr 20 - 3D Systems Appoints Damon Gregoire as VP, CFO Apr 18 - 3D Systems to Hold Investor Day on May 1 in Detroit Apr 09 - 3D Systems Receives NASDAQ Delisting Notice Mar 28 - 3D Systems to Offer Fractional Ownership of RP Systems Mar 19 - 3D Systems Introduces Accura 55 Plastic for SLA Systems Mar 16 - Tangible Express Purchases 10 3D Systems SLA, SLS Systems Feb 16 - 3D Systems Continues to be Listed on NASDAQ Feb 15 - 3D Systems CFO Fred Jones to Retire Feb 7 - 3D Systems Plans 1st User Meeting in September Feb 5 - 3D Systems Q3 Revenue Down 2% to $31.5M, Net Loss of... Jan 18 - 3D Systems Opens Global Headquarters at Rock Hill, SC Jan 18 - 3D Systems to Hold Conference Call on Investor Day
Source: Material used in press releases is often supplied by external
sources and used as is.
|